Licensed, Bonded & Insured in Washington info@firstchoiceroofservice.com Toll-free 1-800-766-3927

Customer story · Roof Replacement

“During My Deployment”: Ryan Watson's Roof Replacement Review

Ryan Watson reviewed the roof replacement on his home in July 2025. He wrote about a competitive quote, a careful cleanup, and how the company treated his wife while he was away.

Two-story home with a gray roof, an American flag on the front porch, a two-car garage and a driveway
The photo Ryan posted with his review, showing the front of the house and its gray roof. Photo: Ryan Watson on Google

“During my deployment, First Choice Roof Service treated my wife with the utmost courtesy and respect, which was a massive relief for me.”

— Ryan Watson

What Ryan wrote

Ryan Watson left a five-star Google review in July 2025 after First Choice replaced the roof on his home. Our reply was simple: “it's my pleasure to help you with your house roof replacement.”

Most of the review covers the job itself. Ryan wrote that the team was “prompt and thorough,” that they cleaned up “every bit of debris,” and that they made “any necessary repairs to the roof that were needed.” The line that stands out, though, is about his family: “During my deployment, First Choice Roof Service treated my wife with the utmost courtesy and respect, which was a massive relief for me.”

That sentence says a lot in a few words. When one person is away, the person at home can end up managing a project they did not plan to manage alone, with a crew working overhead. How a contractor treats that person matters as much as the shingles.

The one photo Ryan posted shows the front of a two-story home with a gray roof, an American flag on the porch and a two-car garage.

Comparing quotes without giving up quality

Ryan wrote that, out of all the quotes he received, First Choice's “was the most competitive—without sacrificing quality or professionalism.” That is the balance most homeowners are trying to strike, and it is far easier when the quotes you are comparing describe the same job.

Before you compare totals, line the bids up on scope:

  • Tear-off. Is the old roof coming off down to the decking, and is disposal included?
  • Underlayment and flashing. What goes under the shingles, and are the chimney, wall and vent flashings new or reused?
  • Ventilation. Are ridge and intake vents part of the plan?
  • Decking repairs. How is damaged wood priced if the crew finds it?
  • Shingle product. Which manufacturer and line? First Choice installs Owens Corning, Malarkey, CertainTeed and IKO shingles.
  • Cleanup. Is a full yard and driveway cleanup part of the job?

A lower number that leaves out tear-off or flashing is not really lower. A written estimate that spells these out lets you compare fairly, and our guide on how to choose a roofing contractor in Washington covers the other questions worth asking.

When you can't be home for your roof replacement

Deployments, work travel, caring for a parent, a second home: there are plenty of reasons the person who arranged a reroof is not the person at the house while it happens. A roof replacement is outdoor work and doesn't need anyone inside, but someone has to be reachable. A little planning makes it much easier on whoever is at home.

  • Name one point of contact. Tell the contractor who makes decisions while you are away, and make sure that person has a copy of the written estimate.
  • Agree on how changes are approved. If the crew finds damaged decking, who signs off, and how quickly do they need an answer?
  • Ask for photos. Pictures of the old roof, any problem areas and the finished work let you follow the job from wherever you are. First Choice photo-documents its inspections.
  • Talk through the practical details. Where trucks and the dumpster go, when the noise starts, and whether pets, cars or garden pots need moving.

Our guide to replacing a roof when you can't be home walks through this step by step.

Repairs and cleanup: the parts you notice afterward

Two details in Ryan's review are easy to skip past, but they matter on every reroof. The first is repairs. When the old shingles come off, the crew sees the roof deck for the first time, and any rot or soft spots should be fixed before new roofing goes on. Ask any contractor how they will show you what they found and how you will approve the fix.

The second is cleanup. Ryan wrote that the crew left “our property spotless.” A tear-off produces a lot of old shingles, nails and underlayment scraps, and some of it lands in beds, lawns and gutters however careful the crew is. A thorough cleanup includes clearing the gutters of granules and debris, sweeping the driveway and running a magnet over the lawn for nails.

If you can, walk the property with the crew before they leave. If you can't be there, ask the person at home to do it, or ask for photos. Our roof replacement page explains how First Choice approaches the work from inspection to cleanup.

In Ryan's Own Words

Ryan WatsonLocal Guide · 30 reviews
Google review
★★★★★

These guys did an exceptional job replacing our roof. Out of all the quotes we received, theirs was the most competitive—without sacrificing quality or professionalism. The team was not only prompt and thorough but also exuded professionalism, ensuring the job was completed correctly from start to finish. They went above and beyond by cleaning up every bit of debris, leaving our property spotless, and making any necessary repairs to the roof that were needed.

During my deployment, First Choice Roof Service treated my wife with the utmost courtesy and respect, which was a massive relief for me. Their communication, quality, and professionalism not only met but exceeded our expectations. I’ll be recommending them to all my neighbors and anyone in need of a roof replacement. It was truly a top-notch experience that provided us with peace of mind.

Posted July 28, 2025 · See Ryan's review on Google ↗
Reply from First Choice

Thanks Ryan it's my pleasure to help you with your house roof replacement

Questions This Story Answers

Do I need to be home during a roof replacement?

No, but someone should be reachable. A roof replacement is outdoor work, so nobody needs to be inside, yet questions do come up, especially if damaged decking is found once the old roof is off. Name one decision-maker, give them the written estimate, and agree ahead of time on how photos and change approvals will be shared.

How should I compare roof replacement quotes?

Compare scope before price. Check that each quote covers full tear-off and disposal, underlayment, new flashing at chimneys, walls and vents, ventilation, the shingle manufacturer and product line, how decking repairs are priced, and cleanup. A quote that leaves one of these out can look lower without being the same job. Ask for everything in writing.

What happens if the roofer finds damaged decking?

A careful crew stops, shows you, and explains before replacing it. Rotted or soft decking can only be seen once the old shingles come off, so ask before the job starts how it will be priced, who approves the extra work, and whether you will get photos. New shingles laid over damaged wood will not perform the way they should.

Will I get photos of my roof if I can't be there?

Ask for them. First Choice photo-documents its inspections, so you can see the condition of the roof before any work is agreed. During any roofing job, ask the contractor for photos of problem areas they uncover and of the finished roof, especially the parts you can't see from the ground, like the flashing and the ridge.

Get the same care on your roof

Free inspections and written estimates across the Greater Puget Sound — call or send a request.