“The crew was professional, on time, and left everything clean when they were done.”
— Snt Cruze
A roof replacement in Seattle, in the homeowner's words
In August 2025, a Seattle homeowner who posts on Google as Snt Cruze left a five-star review after First Choice replaced their roof. Our reply the same day confirmed the job: “it is a pleasure replacing your roof in Seattle.”
The review is light on drama and heavy on the things that make a reroof go well. The homeowner wrote that the crew was “professional, on time, and left everything clean when they were done,” that “The whole process was straightforward,” and that “communication was clear from start to finish.”
Those three points line up with what most people worry about before a roof replacement. Will the crew show up when they said? Will the yard and driveway be covered in nails and old shingles? Will anyone tell me what is going on? This homeowner's answers were yes, no and yes, and they closed by recommending First Choice to “anyone in the Seattle area looking for a new roof or repairs.”
What the homeowner's photos show
All three photos were taken up on the roof. One looks down a hip line from near the top, across gray composition shingles and two roof vents, to a residential street with parked cars, houses and tall evergreens. The other two show the main roof plane with a brick chimney, a row of vents near the ridge and a pipe vent coming up through the shingles.
Photos like these are worth asking for on any roofing job, because they show the parts of a roof you can't see from the sidewalk. When you look at pictures of a finished roof, check a few things:
- Straight, even courses. Shingle rows should run in clean lines without waves or obvious gaps.
- Chimney flashing. The metal where shingles meet the chimney should sit tight to the masonry and be lapped so water runs over it, not behind it.
- Vents and pipes. Each one should sit flat, with its flashing tucked under the shingles above it.
- A clear surface. No leftover nails, wrappers or offcuts on the roof.
First Choice photo-documents its inspections, and a before-and-after set of pictures is often the easiest way to understand exactly what was done.
What “clear communication” should cover on a reroof
Clear communication is easy to promise and harder to deliver. On a roof replacement, it usually comes down to a handful of conversations, and you can ask any contractor about each one before you sign.
- The scope, in writing. What is being torn off, what goes back on, and how vents, flashing and the ridge are handled. First Choice provides free inspections and free written estimates, and a written scope is the thing to compare between bids.
- What happens if there is a surprise. Soft or damaged roof decking only shows once the old shingles come off. Ask how that is handled and how you will be told before extra work starts.
- The schedule. First Choice says most residential roof replacements take one to three days. Weather, roof size and repairs underneath can change that, so ask how you will hear about delays.
- Daily cleanup. Where the dumpster or trailer will sit, how landscaping is protected, and how nails are cleared from the driveway and lawn.
When those four things are settled up front, a lot of the uncertainty of a reroof goes away. Our guide on how to choose a roofing contractor in Washington lists more questions worth asking.
Planning a roof replacement on a Seattle home
Seattle has a wide mix of houses, from older Craftsman and Tudor homes to midcentury ramblers and newer construction, and the right approach to a reroof depends on the house. A few questions come up again and again:
- Tear-off or overlay? Removing the old roofing lets the crew see and repair the decking underneath. Laying new shingles over old ones hides whatever is there.
- Ventilation. Vents at the ridge and eaves let an attic shed heat and moisture. A replacement is the natural time to check whether the attic is vented properly.
- Chimneys. Many older Seattle homes have brick chimneys, and the flashing around them is a common leak point. Ask whether it will be replaced or reused.
- Shingle choice. This homeowner singled out the “quality of the shingles and the workmanship.” First Choice installs shingles from Owens Corning, Malarkey, CertainTeed and IKO. Ask any roofer which manufacturer and product line is in your quote so you can look it up yourself.
Our guide to reroofing older Seattle homes goes deeper on each of these, and the Seattle service area page has more on our roofing work in the city.





