“They took good care of us. I will always refer them to people.”
— Kaela Mortenson
Five short sentences from 2019
Kaela Mortenson posted her five-star review in March 2019. It is one of the shortest in this collection, and it doesn't say what work was done, so we won't guess.
What it does say is clear. Her first sentence is “They took good care of us.” She called the crew “Friendly,” called the result “Great work,” and made a promise most reviewers don't make: “I will always refer them to people.”
There is no reply from the company on this one. Kaela is a Google Local Guide, someone who reviews businesses regularly, so this is one review among dozens she has written rather than a one-off.
Short reviews are easy to scroll past. This page is about why they shouldn't be, and what a homeowner can actually learn from one.
What her photos show
Kaela posted two photos with her review. Both show a low-slope roof surfaced in gray granulated roll roofing. In the first, a box vent and a pipe vent come up through the surface, with a lawn and a street beyond. The second looks along a long roll-roofed section at the edge of a building, with a hedge and a neighboring gray house in the background.
The review doesn't say what First Choice did on this roof, so we can only talk about the kind of roof in her photos. Low-slope roofs like this are common on porches, additions, garages and flat-topped buildings. Water drains off them more slowly than off a steep roof, so the weak spots are predictable:
- Seams and laps, where one sheet overlaps the next.
- Penetrations, like the vent and pipe in her photo, where flashing and sealant age.
- Edges, where wind can get under the material and lift it.
- Low spots, where water sits after rain instead of draining away.
If you have a roof like this, look for standing water a day after rain, blistering or cracking in the surface, and lifted edges at the seams. Those are the signs worth having a roofer check.
Why “I will always refer them” carries weight
A star rating is anonymous. A referral is personal. When someone says they will always refer a company, they are putting their own name behind it with friends, family and neighbors, the people they will hear from if the job goes wrong.
That is why a referral is still one of the most useful ways to find a roofer. To get the most out of one, ask the person who referred you a few questions:
- What work was done, and how long ago?
- Did the crew show up when they said they would?
- How did they treat the household and the property?
- Was the final price in line with the estimate?
- Has the roof held up since?
- Would you hire them again?
The answers tell you more than any star count. And if the person who refers you has photos of the job, the way Kaela did, ask to see them.
Why older reviews still matter
A review from 2019 can look dated next to ones from this year. In practice, older reviews do something newer ones can't: they show whether a company's character holds steady over time.
First Choice has been in business for more than 17 years, and as of November 2026 its Google profile holds 238 reviews with a 4.8-star average. What matters more than the count is whether the same words keep showing up. Kaela's “Friendly” in 2019 sits alongside a 2025 Tacoma customer who wrote “Very kind, professional, and throughly,” and a 2026 Black Diamond customer who said the worker “was kind, professional, and did a great job.” One of Google's own topic tags for the profile is kind staff.
When you read reviews for any roofer, look for that kind of consistency across years. A company described as friendly and careful years ago, and still described that way now, is showing you a pattern rather than a lucky week.
When a review is short, check what else is there: photos, the reviewer's history, whether the company replied, and whether the same themes appear in other reviews. You can read the rest of our customer stories on the reviews page, and our guide to choosing a roofing contractor in Washington covers what else to check.




