Licensed, Bonded & Insured in Washington info@firstchoiceroofservice.com Toll-free 1-800-766-3927

Customer story · Re-Roofing (Two Properties)

Two Properties, Two New Roofs, One Contractor

Trish Evans hired First Choice to re-roof two properties. The more recent job took four days and turned out harder than expected, and the review explains why it still earned five stars.

Street view of a single-story home on a sloped lot with a gray roof, landscaping, a driveway and tall evergreens
A single-story home on a sloped lot, from Trish Evans's photos. Photo: Trish Evans on Google

“Shaun's dedication and reliability are truly amazing. The work quality is outstanding”

— Trish Evans

Two re-roofs, one review

Trish Evans's review starts with the headline: "Effectively finished re-roofing for two of our properties!" Then comes the candid part. "The recent project was completed over four days and presented more significant challenges than we had originally foreseen."

The review doesn't say what those challenges were, and we won't guess. What it does describe is how the work was handled. Trish credits Shaun's "dedication and reliability," calls the work quality "outstanding," and says he was patient "in addressing questions and doubts."

Trish also writes that Shaun's "commitment to productivity is unwavering." On a multi-day re-roof that ran into surprises, that is the quality she valued most, and it is a useful reminder of what to weigh when you hire a roofer.

What the photos show

Trish posted twelve photos, and they show at least two different houses. Some are of a single-story home on a sloped lot with a gray roof and tall evergreens, along with views of dark gray shingle slopes, a vent pipe and skylights, a rear deck, a gable end with siding, and the soffit and eaves from below.

Others show a two-story home. One is a front view with a dark roof. Several catch it mid-project: the old roofing stripped off, the roof deck covered in underlayment, roofers working on the upper roof, and a ladder by the porch. Another shows bundles of shingles staged on the roof, ready to go down.

Those in-progress shots are worth a closer look, because they show a stage most homeowners never see.

What happens under the shingles

A re-roof is a sequence. In general, the old roofing comes off, the wood decking underneath is inspected, damaged sections are dealt with, underlayment goes down as a water-resistant layer, and then flashing, shingles, vents and ridge cap go on. The underlayment stage in Trish's photos is the middle of that sequence: the house is protected, but the finished roof isn't on yet.

This is also when surprises tend to appear. Soft decking, rot or old repairs hidden under the previous roof can't be fully seen until the roof is open. That is general background, not a description of either of Trish's projects, but it is one of the usual reasons a re-roof runs longer than planned. Our explainers on roof underlayment and tear-off versus roofing over cover what each step does. It is also worth asking how the estimate handles decking repairs, so a surprise under the old roof becomes a known line item instead of a dispute.

When a re-roof takes longer than planned

Most residential roof replacements take one to three days, according to First Choice. Trish's more recent project took four, and the review mentions it without complaint. The quality still earned the highest score Trish could think of: "If I could, I'd rate him and his team 10 out of 10."

If you're planning a replacement, build some slack into the schedule. Ask the contractor what could extend the job, such as decking repairs, weather or a complicated roofline, and how they will tell you if it happens. A clear answer, before work starts, to the question of what happens if they find something matters more than the original day count. See how long a roof replacement takes for the full picture.

Planning a re-roof on more than one property

Re-roofing two buildings isn't one big job. It is two separate roofs, each with its own age, pitch, decking and quirks. General advice for owners in that position:

  • Get each roof inspected and estimated on its own. A single bundled number hides which roof is driving the cost.
  • Stagger the work if you can. Finishing one roof first shows you how the contractor communicates before the second job starts.
  • Keep one point of contact. Trish's review keeps coming back to Shaun, and having one person to bring questions to makes a multi-property project simpler.
  • Tell everyone who uses the building. Share the dates, where materials and debris containers will sit, and that the work is noisy, so nobody is caught off guard on the first morning.
  • Keep the photos. In-progress shots like Trish's are a record of what went under the shingles on each building.

Our guide to re-roofing more than one property covers what to plan for. For a free inspection and written estimate on a roof replacement, call (425) 270-1525.

In Trish's Own Words

Trish EvansLocal Guide · 13 reviews
Google review
★★★★★

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

Effectively finished re-roofing for two of our properties! The recent project was completed over four days and presented more significant challenges than we had originally foreseen.

A big thank you to Shaun and First Choice Home Service for their exceptional efforts. Shaun's dedication and reliability are truly amazing. The work quality is outstanding, and although Shaun might not be the most affable person, his commitment to productivity is unwavering.

Shaun is always patience in addressing questions and doubts. If I could, I'd rate him and his team 10 out of 10.

If you would like to get the roof done right at the first time, call Shaun. He will take care of it for you 🙂 Above and beyond😍

Posted August 11, 2023 · See Trish's review on Google ↗

Trish's Photos

Street view of a single-story home on a sloped lot with a gray roof, landscaping, a driveway and tall evergreens
A single-story home on a sloped lot, from Trish Evans's photos.
Dark gray shingle roof slope with a vent pipe and a skylight
A dark gray shingle slope with a vent pipe and a skylight, two spots that depend on good flashing.
Roof slope with skylights and a pipe seen from below, with tree branches hanging over the roof
Overhanging branches shade the roof and drop needles, which is worth managing after any re-roof.
Rear of a house seen from below, showing the roof edge, a deck and surrounding trees
The rear roof edge and deck, seen from the yard.
Side of a house with a gable roof, siding, a green bin and trees
A gable end of the roof with siding below.
Siding, soffit and eave seen from below, with a gable vent
Soffit, eave and gable vent, the details that sit just below the roof edge.
Multi-tone gray shingle roof slope with greenery in the foreground
A multi-tone gray shingle slope behind the greenery.
Front view of a two-story home with a dark roof, a red car and landscaping
The two-story home in Trish Evans's photos, seen from the street.
Two-story home mid re-roof: old roofing removed, underlayment exposed, roofers on the upper roof, a ladder by the porch
Mid-project, with the old roofing off and the roof deck covered in underlayment.
Roofer working on the roof above a porch, with underlayment visible on the roof deck
A closer view of the roof above the porch at the underlayment stage.
Front of a two-story home with the roof covered in underlayment before shingles are installed
The house protected by underlayment while the new roof goes on.
Corner of a house with underlayment on the roof edge and bundles of shingles staged on the roof
Bundles of shingles staged on the roof, ready to be installed over the underlayment.

Photo: Trish Evans on Google. Photos posted by the customer with their review.

What This Review Tells You About Hiring a Roofer

  • Problems under old roofing can stretch a re-roof past the usual one to three days, so ask up front how surprises are handled.
  • On a multi-day project, a contractor who answers questions patiently matters as much as speed.
  • When re-roofing more than one property, have each roof inspected and estimated separately.

Questions This Story Answers

How long does it take to re-roof a house?

Most residential roof replacements take one to three days, according to First Choice Roof Service. Size, pitch, layers of old roofing, decking repairs and weather can all extend that. Trish Evans's review notes that her more recent project took four days and was more challenging than expected, which is why it pays to ask what could lengthen your job before it starts.

What is the layer that goes on a roof before the shingles?

That is underlayment. It goes over the wood roof deck once the old roofing is removed and acts as a water-resistant layer beneath the shingles. It also protects the house while the roof is open. Trish Evans's photos show a two-story home at this stage, with underlayment down and bundles of shingles staged on the roof.

Should I use the same roofer for more than one property?

It can make things simpler if the first job goes well. One contractor and one point of contact means fewer people to brief and a consistent standard across buildings. Still, have each roof inspected and quoted on its own, since every roof has its own condition. Trish Evans used First Choice for two properties and singled out Shaun's reliability.

What should I ask a roofer before a re-roof?

Ask what happens if they find damaged decking once the old roof is off, how they will tell you and get your approval, and how that could change the schedule. Also ask who your point of contact is and how the site will be cleaned up. First Choice provides free inspections and free written estimates; call (425) 270-1525.

Get the same care on your roof

Free inspections and written estimates across the Greater Puget Sound — call or send a request.